Poetical Math

Over the past year, I have heard my friend, mathematician Manjul Bhargava, give several public lectures on the deep connections between poetry, Sanskrit and mathematics.

Each day I post a new Online MCAT CARS Passage. This is for anyone who wants to practice for the Critical Analysis and Reasoning Section.

Every article is selected to meet the AAMC MCAT criteria for MCAT CARS.

Subscribe by email to receive a new free practice passage each morning.

July 20, 2017 – Free MCAT CARS Practice

Question: What is your summary of the author’s main ideas. Post your own answer in the comments before reading those made by others.

Over the past year, I have heard my friend, mathematician Manjul Bhargava, give several public lectures on the deep connections between poetry, Sanskrit and mathematics. Like many other mathematicians before him who have written or spoken on this topic, Manjul gave an array of examples that demonstrate the tremendous depth and contributions made by ancient Indian (for the purposes of exposition, stretching perhaps from present day Afghanistan to Burma) philosophers and poets to mathematics, often before their counterparts in Western societies did the same. Manjul’s quintessential example is from roughly 11th century India, when Gopala and Hemachandra discovered a delightful connection between the number of syllables in Sanskrit poetry and mathematics. The answer, it turns out, is what we now call the Fibonacci series (also appears in the number of petals in certain flowers in nature), which was eventually rediscovered by Leonardo of Pisa, better known as Fibonacci, about 50-80 years later.

That there should be an inherent connection between the number of syllables in Sanskrit poetry, a product of human thought, and the number of petals in flowers in nature must startle any reasonable person. Another extraordinary example that Manjul highlights is the discovery of the binomial structure hidden in Sanskrit poetry, as discovered by the ancient Indian poet Pingala, roughly in 200 BC. This was about 1,800 years prior to the French mathematician Pascal’s Traité du triangle arithmétique, which we today learn as Pascal’s triangle. Other examples include the use of techniques that resemble modern error-correcting codes, synchronisation, and formal language definition in Sanskrit poetry and prose. These are all modern inventions (or reinventions, in some cases) that impact almost every aspect of our lives, from computer languages to wireless communications.

It would, of course, be foolhardy to claim the ancients invented or knew of computer languages or wireless communications. That would be like claiming Copernicus built space ships to fly to the moon. Rather, what these examples do highlight is that a long time ago, in or near the region we live in today, there existed a thriving civilization that produced extraordinary intellectual thought and ideas which continue to have fundamental connections with the way we live today. We appear to have lost knowledge of this ancient past through the vicissitudes and vagaries of time. And with it, a significant source of pride and the ability to influence modern Indian identity. Few people of my generation appear to be aware of these facts.

Part of our ongoing ignorance of the past appears to be structural. Case in point: At my high school in Bangalore, as part of the ICSE syllabus, we read Hamlet, Merchant of Venice, works by Wordsworth, Tennyson, James Joyce, Dickens, etc. We even read Walt Whitman wax eloquent about the end of the American Civil War and Abe Lincoln’s death in “O Captain! my Captain! our fearful trip is done”. Never mind the fact that none of us in class knew what a civil war was at the time, or that America had one, or how or why Lincoln died. We read the tremendously uplifting lines from Tennyson’s “Ulysses”: “To strive, to seek, to find, and not to yield”, all while lacking the context of ancient Greece or even knowing how to say “Ithaca” (we learnt it as EYE-THA-KA). We had little or no context for these strange ideas, words, phrases, stories, heroes and worlds.

And yet, we read these poems, short stories, novels, and wrote essays about them to pass our school exams. This was an enjoyable experience and I would do it again. However, such an educational experience and exposure was severely stunted in its diversity of thought and ideas. What strikes me as odd is that we students never read any classics that originated in this part of the world — that is, ancient India — despite having a cultural advantage of perhaps being able to understand the context better. We knew of no texts, poems, plays, great prose, science, mathematics, civics, political life or philosophy from 2,000-plus years ago from ancient India. My friends and I, stereotypes of the urban educated populace, remained entirely unaware of the intellectual contributions of this past. The most we seemed to know were a couple of random dates and trinkets of information on the Indus Valley civilisation, Ashoka and Chandragupta Maurya, all of which seemed almost perfunctory and without any depth in the manner we read them in school.

As students, we were well versed with Plato, Aristotle, Pythagoras, Copernicus, Newton, Leibniz, Pascal, Galois, Euler, etc, and their tremendous contributions to mankind. And yet, most of us had never read about Aryabhatta, Brahmagupta, Pingala, Kalidasa, Hemachandra, Madhava, the Nyaya or Mimimsa Sutras, or the Therigatha.

But why bother with any of this? After all, we were never part of these accomplishments and they were so long ago, by a people so far removed from today’s reality, that attempting to create any link to the past is surely irrelevant. But I would argue this discovery of the past is no less relevant than what we already study and acknowledge in the earlier cited examples in our schools and colleges. Besides, these sources of knowledge from ancient India are products of creative human thought and hold genuine value for the world, irrespective of where they come from, or geographic affinities. For example, any child on this planet will find mathematics far more amenable when learning parts of it through poetry, as opposed to the dry, dull methods espoused by most mathematics pedagogy today.

While national identity is a complex phenomenon, perhaps in some proportion it relates to the intellectual contributions made by societies to help advance knowledge and improve the human condition. Newton is a hero to many like me, who read in wonder about how he unravelled the basic laws of the universe. Great literature and philosophy from Western societies have helped us reflect on the human condition. Such examples from the Western world have magnified our respect for societies that could harbour, enable and encourage such curiosity. In the same vein, we stand to gain much from developing an understanding of ancient India, its deep and diverse ideas, which are no less extraordinary than those we have come to marvel in Western civilizations. I am not suggesting we lose respect for contributions made by other societies or civilisations, or that everything of note was discovered in this part of the world. Rather, we ourselves have much to gain when we dispassionately discover, examine and acknowledge the intellectual history of ancient India. We may be surprised to find it was perhaps a more open, tolerant and diverse society than even the one we have lived in since Independence. If you need more convincing or inspiration, look up Manjul’s talk on YouTube. Or try reading the Therigatha.

Adapted from Indian Express.

Review

Leave a comment below with what you understood to be the author’s main ideas. Ask about this daily passage in office hours/workshops for help.

Subscribe to my Daily CARS mailing list by entering your email.

The full list of daily articles is available here.

Have a great day.
Jack Westin
MCAT CARS Instructor.
Contact Information

15 Comments


  1. The author is fascinated by Manjula’s works of relating math to Sanskrit poetry, but denounces the idea that any ancients were the first to create the things we experience today. Rather, they serve as a stepping stone that helped pave the way for intellects to gain upon.
    The author examines his own upbringing and how he was critical of the fact that his own curriculum did not include ancient Indian texts because he is a firm believer that ancient India had a lot to offer to modern civilization.

    Tone: Critical of the schooling system of India (particularly the one he went to) but accepting of the idea that ancient India has much to offer.

    Reply

  2. connections between poetry, Sanskrit, and math, Indian history important

    Reply

  3. MIP: reading of Indian lit = important bc learning from past +ideas
    but, there is lack of reading of Indian lit

    Reply

  4. MI1: There are connections in mathematics and Sanskrit poetry, suggesting the ancient Indians knew more about mathematics than previously believed, and may predate when these ideas were first fathomed elsewhere.
    MI2: Although there may be intellectual contribution from ancient Indians, not institutionally implemented in education. Even in India, with cultural context, author learned classics from western world. Also argues literature would be a good way to learn mathematics rather than how it is often taught in school.

    Author tone: Humble, not trying to downplay contributions from Western world, suggesting positively that there is more to learn and gain from studying what the ancient Indians discovered

    Reply

  5. Bhargava looks at mathematics, and poetry together and the author looks at the historical Indian origins of these things. India has a rich history of knowledge of mathematics but it is overshadowed by European knowledge. This continues in the reader’s life in school as they learn and admire the western world’s literature but forgo learning about their own culture. The author admires western thinkers such as Newton but also suggests that people should look at Indian heritage more and see what knowledge it has to offer.

    Reply

  6. India’s history is often overlooked in the U.S education system, but it has many meaningful scientists and discoveries that would enhance education.

    Reply

  7. The structure of modern education in the US places less emphasis on the significance of ancient India and its people. Author believes knowledge of Ancient India has much more to offer to human civilization and uses the connection between Sanscrit poetry and Math as an example

    Reply

  8. MIP: Math and poetry are connected ex) Fibornica Ex) pascal. Ancient Indian thought is not studied, even though it has played great contributions to knowledge.

    Reply

  9. Math and Sanskrit poetry related; ancient Indian history should be studied

    Reply

  10. MIP
    (1) Sanskrit poetry + math = connected (Bhargava)
    (2) Indian before Western world (Bhargava)
    (3) Learn things w/o context; context learning = important
    (4) Learn Western influencers but not Indian
    (5) Learning Western = great + increase knowledge; should do same for Indian

    Tone
    Positive

    Reply

  11. Author brings up important point: There is a connection between poetry, Sanskrit, and Mathematics, and this connection is brought forward by realizing the significance of studying Ancient Indian works. Author sees the overall significance of studying Western works, introducing the ideas of curiosity and diversity of thought, but he also sees the benefit of studying Ancient Indian works (knowledge, inspiration, and diversity)

    Reply

  12. Past math connects to poem(RTA: Bhargava) + modern inventions.
    Indian ignore such connection, b/c learning without context + score driven.
    connection=important
    national identity influences such recognition.

    Reply

  13. MIP: Connection b/w Sanskrit and Math, Students ignorant of Indian literature, Call for curriculum to focus on India’s history

    Reply

  14. Ancient Indian knowledge = ignored, should be studied and will be beneficial for education.

    Reply

  15. Ancient India has startling discoveries that are overlooked for structural/educational reasons. They are offer value and insight into the human condition, and may be of educational use.

    Reply

Leave a Reply